Why Do We Always Think of the Perfect Thing to Say After the Fact

Why Do We Always Think of the Perfect Thing to Say After the Fact

Why do we always think of the perfect thing to say after the fact?

I’ve spent the last 72 hours agonizing over this. Like tummy-ache, head in a vice, can’t-turn-my-racing-brain-off kind of agonizing.

It all started with an email. A producer from Minnesota Public Radio asked me if I’d like to be on Kerri Miller’s Friday Roundtable discussion. These are where Miller (a beloved radio host with the best voice on the planet) has an hour-long conversation with “three smart people.” I’ve done this show before, and left walking on a cloud of cotton candy and Smarties. Go me! When we recorded this time, I started out as one of these three smart people.

By the end of the conversation, I didn’t feel that way.

Our topic was books we’ve lied about reading. The premise: a lot of people have guilt about not reading the classics, or having never read Harry Potter. I loved this idea! I imagined we’d talk about WHY we tell white lies. To sound smart! To fit in! To partake in a lively conversation! Plus, I had a great story about lying about reading the Brother’s Karamozov in high school just so I could get a t-shirt for completing the task.

My fellow roundtablers were Enrique Olivarez Jr., Vice President of Development and Communications at CLUES (Comunidades Latinas Unidas en Servicio), and R. Vincent Moriz Jr., a writer and speaker in the Twin Cities. Both seemed like nice guys, and both are definitely well-read. I knew that within the first three seconds, when Miller asked posed a question about reading books by Minnesota author Louise Erdrich.

Now, to be clear: neither Olivarez nor Moriz had really read any of Erdrich’s books.

But I’m sitting there thinking, Oh $#!&. I don’t even know who we’re talking about! I had two options: lie and say I knew of her but hadn’t read any of her books either, or throw caution to the wind and fess up. I chose the latter, because it was the truth, and I was sure there would be at least one person listening who was like phew! Thank god I’m not the only one who didn’t know! 

So I said it: Never heard of her.

I felt no shame in admitting this. After all, I can’t change the fact that I’d never come into contact with these books. I was proud of myself for being real.

However, after my admission, something changed. Or at least it did in my head. I felt judged. I felt like Miller thought who in the hell vetted this gal for my show? I may be mistaken, but I can almost swear that later in the hour, when she reintroduced the show, she said “This is the Friday roundtable, where I have an hour-long conversation with what I thought were three smart people.”

This just might be my hormonal, pregnant brain projecting.

But in my mind, that happened. Anyhow, I spent the rest of the hour (the FULL hour!), trying to assert that I indeed did know how to read. As the conversation unfolded, I felt more and more insecure about what I have and have not read. I’m more of a non-fiction gal, and the conversation skewed more toward fiction. The more titles of books I’d never read swirled around my head, the more insecure I became.

I realized half way through that I probably had some major balls for showing up for a discussion about books on a smarty-pants platform like MPR.

I fumbled my way through the rest of the interview (at least, that’s what I recall). I admitted to reading all of 50 Shades of Grey! (Whatever, you read it too. E.L. James didn’t get rich because that book wasn’t popular.) When asked which books I’ve read lately, I mustered up Station Eleven (a great read!) and then Crazy Rich Asians (!), an addictive beach read about, well, crazy-rich Asians.

As I left the studio, my brain started coming up with all the “right” answers.

  • Why didn’t I say that I love reading non-fiction because I’m a non-fiction writer myself?
  • Why didn’t I say that I love reading essays, memoirs, books about historical events and biographies? I’ve read all of David Sedaris’s books, am obsessed with Anne Lamott, am currently reading Joan Didion, and recently poured over Erik Larson’s Devil in the White City and In the Garden of Beasts. All of these are great books, not fluff, and would’ve made me seem like the smart person they wanted me to be!
  • Why didn’t I say that I’ve been enjoying reading light, fluffy fiction because I’m pregnant and just can’t handle reading anything heavy right now? Hormones!
  • Why didn’t I say that while I think “required reading” in school is important, I’ve never had an assigned book resonate with me as much as any book I chose to read?

Why, why, why!

Look, I did the best I could. I am convinced that pregnancy brain is a thing, and it does make you forget names of people, places, and yes, books.


I also realized the my feelings leaving this conversation are exactly why most of us lie about having read certain books. It’s because we so often equate being well-read with intelligence. I certainly read a lot, but I read for fun. The people I hang out with don’t care what I’ve read and what I haven’t, and that’s one of many reasons I love them. I read as an escape, a way to unwind and relax. I am still smart, even if the closest I got to reading the Grapes of Wrath was watching the movie.

I did read East of Eden a few years ago. Well, most of it.

We lie about reading because we don’t want to look foolish.

I left feeling very foolish. At least I can laugh about it. I have laughed about it quite a bit. But if I’m being really honest, I cried once, too. HA!

However, if I recall correctly, I did make one good point: If required reading in school never resonates with a student, there is a good chance they may never pick up a book again. They may think of themselves as a non-reader for life, and that’s never good. That’s why we really shouldn’t shame people for what they haven’t read. Instead, let’s encourage people, especially young people, to read what they like. Even if it’s comic books or thrillers or Crazy Rich Asians.

As an aside, this ordeal showed me just how much my brain has changed while pregnant. Normally, I’d just let something like this roll off my back, but wow. I’m so much more fragile that I realized! It’s a good reminder to be kinder to myself and avoid unnecessarily stressful situations whenever possible.

It’ll be interesting to listen to the interview when it airs on MPR (date TBD!). It’s probably not as bad as I remember, and hopefully I made a big deal out of nothing. And, fingers crossed, at least one person thought it was funny when I admitted to reading 50 Shades of Grey on public radio.

*** UPDATE: ***
Here’s a link to the interview. I haven’t had the balls to listen yet!

* * *

Twice a year, I ask friends for book recommendations and they deliver big-time! Here’s a list from last summer, and another list from the holidays. Happy reading!

Oh, and just for fun: here’s the last time I felt like I made an ass of myself in a very public forum (aka The Time I Didn’t Know I Was Giving a TEDx Talk). I heard from a lot of people after the fact who actually looked me up to say I did a great job… unsolicited! Goes to show you’re your own worst critic.



(plus a FREE copy of 107 Ways to Expand Your Comfort Zone)

Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.

I completely respect your privacy.

You might also like

Comments (11)

  • Melissa Joulwan 5 years ago Reply

    Oh, honey. I’m sure when you listen back it won’t be as bad as it felt… and also, kind of: SCREW THEM for producing those feelings in you. Plus, even if it was awful (which I’m so totally sure it wasn’t), how many people will hear it? Hundreds? thousands? In the grand scheme, that’s no so much… and you, as always, have the guts to DO stuff. Brilliant. It reminds me of a few lines from Jane Eyre:

    I was the first who spoke—

    “Helen, why do you stay with a girl whom everybody believes to be a liar?”

    “Everybody, Jane? Why, there are only eighty people who have heard you called so, and the world contains hundreds of millions.”

    (Jane Eyre has an answer for everything. Truly.)

    molly mogren katt 5 years ago Reply

    I love you! I’m sure it’s not as bad as I thought, and I swear it just played off some deep insecurity I didn’t even know I had! Learning is fun.

    PS Jane Eyre is one of the books I have read, cover to cover!

  • Alyssa Tuma 5 years ago Reply

    I’m actually positive that upon listen you will sound funny and wonderful and SMART. (And probably incredibly relatable and human–don’t discount the J.Law factor, people love that!!!)

    If you’re looking for a great Erdrich read, I recommend the Round House. Although it’s flippin’ dark as hell and I maybe wouldn’t recommend it to a pregnant woman. But it’s very accessible and fast-paced, which is maybe why it’s one of the few Erdrich books I’ve finished. Oops! did I just admit that? 😉

    molly mogren katt 5 years ago Reply

    I like the sound of fast-paced! And I am banking on the J.Law factor, too. If nothing else, I’ll think I’m funny. Maybe.

  • Cindy 5 years ago Reply

    This is my nightmare and curse! I always feel like I say the wrong thing and think of the right thing to say later. In college I read 1/4 of Infinite Jest because all the people in my workshop class talked about it all the time and one of the guys once told me that I used $2 words when a 5cent word would suffice (DOUCHE), so I felt like I needed to read something cool to fit in? I still don’t even know what I wanted to prove but, I never could finish it.

    PS, I read Station Eleven and really enjoyed it, too!

    molly mogren katt 5 years ago Reply

    You did finish Infinite Jest? Cindy, you are such a loser! 😉

    Thanks for sharing your story. I think most of us have those moments when we think "WHY DIDN’T I SAY _ AT THE TIME?!" I guess we’re all just human.

  • Brian Mogren 5 years ago Reply

    Omg!!! I am so sorry you went through this! It sounds like one’s worst nightmare–on steroids. It did, however, make for a HYSTERICAL blog!

    And, it’s probably not as bad as you think. And if it is, oh well! There are worse things than bombing on public radio. You are still AWESOME. I would say even more so! While life will go on, and people will forget the episode (after, of course, talking about it at snooty dinner parties across the city that night), you will have a great story to charm and entertain people with for years to come! And those snooty types will remain forever in the stands of life, all self-conscious and critiquing those who are on the court playing full out. You truly inspire me with your hutzpah and honesty. Keep writing and taking chances, girl, and inspiring and entertaining many of us along the way! Love, Uncle Brian

    molly mogren katt 5 years ago Reply

    Thanks, Uncle Brian! As I mentioned in an email to you earlier this day, in the midst of me admitting I’ve read ALL of 50 Shades of Grey, I thought to myself "Oh well, at least Uncle Brian will think this is funny." HA!!! Thanks for your encouragement! Just writing this story down made the whole thing seem so silly. Sometimes, sharing your embarrassment is the best way to get over it. 🙂

  • Molly Dunne 5 years ago Reply

    I totally lie about having read Russian Literature…like, any of it–I mean, who has the time or motivation to read War and Peace by choice?? As an English Lit major and a writer, I think people sort of expect you to have read any book they mention. But I’ll be honest, reading some of the classics just isn’t enjoyable. Not to mention, I don’t think anyone who has read Ulysses outside of a college classroom with a professor providing annotations for every page, could possibly understand it. I did read it in a college class—TWICE!—and I still don’t think I get it.

  • Adrienne Sanders 5 years ago Reply

    I’m going to be pondering this for a while now! Off the top of my head- I don’t think I really fudge about books, but I totally lie about what movies I’ve seen or TV series I’ve watched. No I haven’t seen whatever thing you think is hilarious, b/c I’m not a huge movie watcher and even less so a comedy watcher. I haven’t watched Big Lebowski since it first came out. But I want you to think I’m down with the kids these days, so…. =/

    molly mogren katt 5 years ago Reply

    My thought it you like what you like. So why waste your time watching movie or reading books that don’t appeal to you? Though I will say, I love the Big Lebowski. Consider it 🙂

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.