Why I Started Drinking Bone Broth (& How To Make Your Own!)

Yes, everything I cook looks this pretty. #noitdoesn't
Yes, everything I cook looks this pretty. #noitdoesn’t

Yesterday, I explained why I don’t take naps.

However, I do think that almost everyone needs more sleep.

Though I am getting way more sleep than I was a few years ago (thanks to marrying a guy who hits the sack at 9 pm. It’s completely rubbed off on me!), I still lay in bed almost every night for at least an hour. Waiting…. waiting… waiting… to fall asleep.

Even when I’m tired, I lay awake forever.

I mentioned this to my acupuncturist. She said she wasn’t surprised and that based on my weak pulse, she thought I might be anemic. Might sound like witchdoctor mumbo-jumbo to you, but she then asked if I’m constantly cold and get light headed easily.

Check and check.

She said these symptoms are all related and asked me to try three things:

  • Eat two ounces of red meat a day
  • Eat a daily serving of strawberries or raspberries
  • Drink a cup of homemade bone broth two or three times a day

This is the same lady who fixed my plantar fasciitis in one treatment and made my headaches go away. I don’t know how this acupuncture stuff works, I just know it does. I’d rather treat ailments with food than with drugs, so I followed her prescription.

The red meat and berry thing seems pretty straightforward.

But the bone broth… wtf is that?

To be quite honest, just the sound of it revolts me. I know it’s just homemade stock, which I’ve made dozens of times, but we have to call it bone broth now?! Gross.

(PS store-bought stock does not have the same health benefits… you can read about that here.)

Despite my ill feelings toward the stuff, I did a modified version of Whole 9’s recipe.

Here’s the basics:

  • 1 gallon water
  • 2 tablespoons apple cider vinegar
  • 2 large onions, unpeeled and quartered (I used an onion and remnants from some leeks/scallions… bone broth is flexible like that)
  • 2 carrots, coarsely chopped
  • 3 celery stalks (tops included!), chopped
  • 1 bunch fresh herbs (parsley, rosemary and oregano will all work here)
  • 2-3 garlic cloves, lightly smashed
  • 2-4 lbs. meat or poultry bones
  • Kosher salt to taste (start out with a teaspoon)

Bring all this stuff to a boil in a stockpot, then simmer on low for 12-14 hours (more time = more flavor). Yes, that likely means you might be leaving something on your stovetop overnight. EEEK! I’ve done it three times and lived to tell the tale. Honestly, it’s no sketchier than putting something in a crockpot and leaving your house for the day.


Yep, this looks ugly now. Not all food on the Internet is gorgeous... deal with it!
Yep, this looks ugly now. Not all food on the Internet is gorgeous… deal with it!

Once your broth is done, it’s time to strain. You’ll need a mesh strainer and some sort of container (I used a Pyrex bowl).

A mesh strainer is the quickest method, but does leave some solids in your broth. If you’re cool with that, good for you. If not, your can filter the broth again with cheesecloth (or a coffee filter if you have all day).

So not Pinterest-worthy. 
So not Pinterest-worthy.

Because I already have a mental hurdle between me and drinking bone broth, I’m storing the contents in an easily pourable pitcher. This way I have no excuse to not do it.

On day one, I took some broth directly from the stockpot. I sipped on a mug (#277). It was delicious.

Bone broth, stored in a convenient pitcher. 
Bone broth, stored in a convenient pitcher.

Two weeks in and I’m happy to report I’m falling asleep notably faster. Like within 10 minutes of laying down. I’m also sleeping through the night. This is just the tip of the iceberg as far as bone broth’s purported health benefits go. It’s anti-inflammatory, helps repair muscles, mends a leaky gut and makes your hair and nails absolutely fabulous.

If you’re having sleep issues, I say give this a shot.

Cheaper than sleeping pills, with less weird side effects.

And if you’re a vegetarian, I guess you’re stuck with Sleepytime Tea (which is also delicious).

* * *

Are you a bone broth devotee? Why? And PS this isn’t the first time I tried alternative healthcare methods: I once got needled in the face, signed up for a energy healing session from this dude and that one time I tried colon hydrotherapy.

Sign up with your email address to receive news and updates.

I completely respect your privacy.

You might also like

Comments (15)

  • Whitney 6 years ago Reply

    Did you just go to the meat counter and ask for 5 lbs of bones?

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    Yes, Whitney & Paige… you do exactly that. Know thy butcher! Of course it’s best to use bones from humanely raised, anti-biotic free, blah blah blah animals. Just like any other time you cook with protein!

  • Diana 6 years ago Reply

    Oooh I do keep bone broth (sorry) on hand for cooking and occasional drinking. I’m doing a whole100 (ugh more later) for various health reasons and this can only help! SOLD.

    I also have been known to leave this simmer for eeeeeeeeeeever in a crockpot. it works.

    PS solids in your broth? wtf gross

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    Maybe by solids, I meant floating bits of stuff, like herbs, probably. I hope. Maybe that’s not what those are. Good for you on the Whole100! I’m not even going to ask how far you are into it….

  • Paige 6 years ago Reply

    Mine is the same question as Whitney, I feel a bit silly that I don’t know where to find bones…

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    Ask at the meat counter. They’ll hook you up!

  • Carly 6 years ago Reply

    Does it get all jell-o like in the pitcher?

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    Yes, a bit. But it’s supposed to. Once you warm it up, it’s normal again. Just don’t think about it.

  • Sarah 6 years ago Reply

    Funny – I’m constantly making chicken stock from chicken carcasses whenever we roast a bird. I actually have a ton right now and wasn’t sure what I’d make with it….guess I can just drink the stuff!

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    glug glug gug!

    I’ve also used in place of water in rice or grain recipes. Dee-licious.

  • Diana 6 years ago Reply

    Every time we roast a chicken (or turkey, or chicken wings, or legs, or whatever) I put the bones in a gallon ziploc baggie in the freezer. Once I amass enough remains, I make stock! (I also get chicken feet from my meet vendor at the farmers market. They have soup bones there too that you can just buy!)

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    Yes, all great advice. The chicken feet are probably almost free, too!

  • Kate Sommers 6 years ago Reply

    Bone broth honestly sounds like heaven to me and I oddly have never gotten around to making it. If you ever get the chance to eat at a Neimann Marcus Cafe, they start off your meal with a cup of chicken broth and a pop-over with strawberry butter. I’m sure the pop-over and strawberry butter would offset the goodness of bone broth, but damn, it sounds good to me.

    molly mogren katt 6 years ago Reply

    That sounds so old school! And PS I am drinking my broth right now.

  • Joseph 5 years ago Reply

    Bone broth is awesome. If you make a ton of it I suggest investing in an Instapot pressure cooker. It only take 2 hours and it make fantastic broth!

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.